short essay, feedback appreciated.

I wrote this short essay on volunteering, for a zine submission.
I would really appreciate any and all feedback, good or bad.
Thanks mamas!

When my son started kindergarten at a very small school of 120 students, grades K-6, I became what is know to the PTA as “fresh blood.� Because the district cut funding for art and music in the elementary schools, the PTA put volunteer programs in place to insure students would still get exposure to the arts in their early schooling. My willingness alone suddenly qualified me for becoming an art docent to a combined class of 19 kindergarten and first graders. My having actually taken art classes years and years ago at a college made me influential in helping draw up lesson plans in accordance to district standards. It all happened rather quickly and surprisingly and I appeared to be the only one questioning my sudden qualifications. Having never stood before a classroom as some sort of adult with something to say, something to teach, I started to inwardly panic the night before my first day. I was terrified, not to mention furious with myself for being flattered into this position. How was I going to pull it off?

And then I remembered my first meaningful art lesson, given by an ironworker, (the construction kind, that builds bridges and really tall buildings in downtowns). My dad is conservative. He doesn’t drink, doesn’t smoke, doesn’t swear and most people, respectfully, don’t do those things around him. He’s an upstanding, quiet guy. Not the kind you’d expect to be open-minded.
When I was around ten years old, my family (dad, mom, brother, me), went into Los Angeles on weekends to hit the museums. One time we got adventurous, left the beaten path, and meandered over to the Temporary Contemporary art museum. There we saw an installation piece called “Tree Lover� which consisted of a mechanical man humping a huge plaster tree. I laughed mischievously. I couldn’t wait for my dad to see it, cover my eyes, yell at the museum staff, and whisk us away to the safety of the Children’s Museum. But he only laughed. When I looked up at him, puzzled, he told me that looking at art was like listening to other people’s opinions. That sometimes it’s the only way to be heard.

That’s what I took with me to my son’s class every Friday for seven weeks. Art isn’t something only fancy smart people understand. It’s another way of expressing oneself. We can teach kids history and math, to memorize facts and solve problems with numbers, but it’s through the arts that they learn about themselves and learn empathy for others. There are no wrong answers. Expression through the arts is a power they can harness even in the seemingly powerlessness of childhood.
I ended up throwing out half of the lesson plans. I didn’t want to bog them down with vocabulary words and timelines. I passed out the canvas paper, the brushes, and paint. They learned about colors through mixing. We looked at pictures of artwork and they shouted out the colors they saw, how the colors used made them feel. They shouted out the shapes they recognized. We traced the lines with our fingers. There were no raised hands. I told them to shout it out.

They’re last project was an assemblage/collage piece inspired by Picasso’s violin collage. They used painted boxes, newspaper, string, and other strips of paper with lots of glue, some paint, and messy charcoal. At first they thought it was kind of weird. Was it art?
They were finding that they were already challenging their perceptions of art. They had learned a lot. One of the first graders, while putting his project together, exclaimed that this was one of the best days of his life! For a teacher, a volunteer, inexperienced one, at that, is there any better affirmation?

hippohank.com!

Comment viewing options

Select your preferred way to display the comments and click "Save settings" to activate your changes.

Thank you everyone for the

Thank you everyone for the very helpful comments!
I have a good idea of where to go in fine-tuning this.

hippohank.com!

like it

I really like it. Agree with all that has been said, esp. the part about clarifiying that your dad is the construction worker.

I do think your examples about your dad show that he is "conservative". I mean I know what you're getting at, but maybe there is a better word than conservative. I think it's that word that might be the problem instead of the examples, however I am never discouraging more colorful examples. . .Hope that makes sense.

Part of me wants to know if there have been any ripple effects beyond this experience . . .how you look at art, how you look at your dad, what you think of yourself. Like making this an example in a larger essay. . .about some bigger concept. . .those are my quick thoughts. But I overall really like it and if you would ever want to include it in mombomb "an explosion of maternal creativity" it would be right up our alley. . .

Heather
Mombomb zine

Thank you for your

Thank you for your feedback.
I think for the publication I'm wanting to send this to, this version is more suitable, but I'd love to expand on it for mombomb and explore some of the ripple effects, as you say.
you can email me at beth@hippohank.com.

hippohank.com!

Now we fight over you. No!

Now we fight over you. No! I want it for Lone Star Ma! Just kidding about the fighting, of course, but I honestly would love to print it anytime if you are ever interested. It's great.

i didn't feel confused by

i didn't feel confused by the dad paragraph - don't change it too much, I mean I like how you said I learned art from a construction worker. and then your like - my dad. nice.

little things I would change for flow is

I became what is known *in* the PTA as freshblood (not *of*)

Having actually taken art classes years and years ago (CUT off the *My*)

and when you talk about your family going to the mueseum - I would cut off the paragraph elaborating (brother, sister, mom, dad) ... cuz I dunno, its boring to me. who cares its your family.

I just like to streamline, cut anything that feels a bump

AS always, with a grain of salt take my one second gut reactions.

...
thought it was Great. specially loved the image in my head of the kids with all this stuff and colours and paint and collage and shouting out stuff. how it was the best day.

rock. art is good.

don't have anything to add

other than what splendid already said about the sentence structure making it confusing as to whether your dad was the construction worker who taught you about art.

And the last paragraph "they're" should be "their."

But this is great otherwise.

mechanical-- in the

mechanical-- in the second-to-last paragraph, "they're" should actually be "their".

This paragraph seems disjointed and unclear to me:

"And then I remembered my first meaningful art lesson, given by an ironworker, (the construction kind, that builds bridges and really tall buildings in downtowns). My dad is conservative. He doesn’t drink, doesn’t smoke, doesn’t swear and most people, respectfully, don’t do those things around him. He’s an upstanding, quiet guy. Not the kind you’d expect to be open-minded."

Is your dad the ironworker? I got confused for a second there. Also, I'm not sure those details show that he is conservative-- maybe something more illustrative?

LOVE the rest of the essay-- I think this is a really valuable service you're giving these kids, and love how excited they got to just be experiencing art. I'd like to know a little bit more about you though-- did you ever have any teaching experience? what kind of art did you have experience in? how did your kid like seeing his mom in front of the room? Are you going to continue to do be a volunteer docent?

hope this helps!